AegisAI Perspectives · 129

How do I stop fake CEO emails to new hires at a 100-person fintech startup?

Brief every new hire before day one, verify CEO requests on a second channel, and turn on impersonation settings that cover a mailbox in its first week.

TL;DR
Answer
Warn every new hire before day one that the CEO never emails for gift cards, favours or payments, and give them one callback route outside the email thread.
Who it's for
IT leads at fintech startups of 20 to 500 people on Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace who onboard new staff themselves, with no SOC behind them.
Watch out for
A mailbox under seven days old gets no first contact safety tip in Microsoft 365, and a lookalike domain can pass email authentication checks.
What AegisAI does
One bad email is pulled from every inbox it reached, forwards included. Every verdict comes with its reason in plain language, so your team can check it and share it.
Book a demo

See it on your own Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 tenant. No MX change.

Or get the Q3 2026 State of the AI Attack report (free, instant download)

Not ready for a demo? Check your domain (free, about 10 seconds).

How do I stop fake CEO emails to new hires at a 100-person fintech startup?

Warn every new hire at your fintech startup, before day one, that the CEO never emails for gift cards, favours or payments. Verify any such request on a second channel8. AegisAI investigates every email for what it is trying to do, and removes the ones that fail from every mailbox they reached16. If you run IT for a fintech startup of 20 to 500 people on Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, with a lean IT or security team and no SOC, run the checklist below on each start date.

Filters alone will not close the gap: AegisAI research found 3 in 10 confirmed phishing emails cleared native Gmail and Microsoft filters in Q3 202622. That figure sits on the inbound email security page. For CEO fraud and payroll diversion across the whole company, read how security teams stop CEO fraud and payroll diversion.

What you can do by the end

  • Brief each new hire before day one on the three asks a real CEO never sends by email.
  • Turn on the impersonation settings that still work for a mailbox in its first seven days.
  • Give every new hire one callback route that does not use the email thread.

How do attackers find and exploit new employees?

Scammers are watching, too, and they might use the update to target you1. A post that names the company and the role tells an attacker who to write to and when.

The usual opener is a quick favour from the CEO's name, before the new hire knows how the CEO writes.

Ask new hires to hold their job update until after the first week, or to post it without a start date.

Short on time? Watch the explainer, or book a demo.

Why are new hires prime targets for CEO impersonation?

The new hire has no baseline. Unfamiliar with the company's communication norms and executive team, they might not recognize fraudulent requests15. Employees, especially newer ones, are less likely to question directives that seem to come from the top.

The mailbox has no baseline either. In Microsoft 365, the first contact safety tip is not stamped when the message was sent to a mailbox created less than seven days ago10. The warning a new hire would most need is missing in week one.

Treat the first month after a start date as the highest risk window for that person.

Which red flags mark fake CEO emails during onboarding?

Three asks cover most of it: gift cards, a quick favour that turns into a purchase, or a payment or a change to account details.

The FTC is direct: don't buy gift cards for anyone who contacts you to ask2. Gift cards are for gifts, not for payments4. The same ask hits staff well beyond fintech: see how universities stop payroll diversion and gift card scams.

Payments carry the larger loss. The FBI counted 21,442 business email compromise complaints in 20245, with reported losses of $2,770,151,146. Between December 2022 and December 2023, identified global exposed losses rose 9%7.

The sender address does not settle it. Impersonation can pass email authentication checks if the attacker created a lookalike domain and published valid DNS records9.

Put these three asks, in these words, into the welcome email each new hire gets before day one.

Set verification protocols for HR and security teams

HR owns the welcome note. Security owns the route a new hire uses to check a request.

Give one route that does not touch the email thread. The FBI advice: use secondary channels or two-factor authentication to verify requests for changes in account information. For a new hire, that means a number from the company directory, never one in the email.

Give one person to ask. The FTC advice is to talk to someone you trust before acting3. Make that someone a named manager, not "anyone on the team".

Write the route and the name into the welcome note, under the three asks.

Build a secure onboarding policy against BEC: the day-one checklist

Run it for every new starter, in this order, before the first payment or vendor task lands on their desk.

  1. Send the welcome note before day one: the three asks, the callback route and the named manager. Don't buy gift cards for anyone who contacts you to ask.

  2. In Microsoft 365, turn on the first contact safety tip in the anti-phishing policy. Microsoft recommends you turn it on, because it adds an extra layer of protection against potential impersonation attacks11.

  3. Add the CEO and finance leads as protected users for impersonation, and remember that a mailbox under seven days old gets no first contact tip.

  4. In Google Workspace, turn on protection against messages where the sender's name is a name in your Google Workspace directory12.

  5. Also turn on protection against domains that appear visually similar to your company's domains or domain aliases13.

  6. Show the new hire where the report button is on day one, and ask them to report the first odd request instead of answering it.

Copy these six steps into your onboarding ticket template today.

Compare what each control catches in the new-hire window

ControlWhat it catchesWhat it misses in week oneInbound email security
First contact safety tip (Microsoft 365)A first message from an unfamiliar senderNot stamped on a mailbox under seven days oldCatches fake executives, vendors and payment requests, even with no link or file to scan17
Employee name spoofing (Google Workspace)A display name that matches your directoryA request that uses no display name trickThe verdict rests on what this sender has sent you before and on the request itself21
Email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC)Forged use of your own domainA lookalike domain with valid recordsReads mail through the Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace API after delivery18
Callback on a known numberA payment or account changeA gift card ask the new hire never reportsNo edge. A callback is a people step, and the live product pages describe none
Day-one briefingGift card and favour asksA new hire who skips the emailNo edge. Briefing new hires stays with your team

The last two rows are people steps, so keep them whatever tool you run. Fill in the third column for your own tenant before the next start date.

How AegisAI handles this

AegisAI reads the thread the way an analyst would: the sender's history, the change being asked for, and where the reply actually goes20. One bad email is pulled from every inbox it reached, forwards included23. Every verdict comes with its reason in plain language, so your team can check it and share it24.

Book a demoSee inbound email security

See your own records: Check your domain.

How does a fake CEO email reach a new hire in a worked example?

Illustrative example, figures are fictional: Harbor Ledger (fictional) is a fintech startup of 100 people on Google Workspace with one IT lead. A new payments analyst posts her start on Monday. On Wednesday she gets an email with the CEO's name from a personal address: "Are you at your desk? I need a quick favour." The next message asks for six gift cards for a client event. Her welcome note listed gift cards as one of the three asks the CEO never sends, so she reports it instead of replying. The IT lead finds the same message in four other new starters' inboxes. He deletes all five copies and adds the address to the welcome note as an example.

Time your next report like this one: from the moment the email arrives to the moment it is gone from every inbox.

How to measure it in 30 days

Track three numbers, each from a record you already keep.

  • Share of new hires who got the welcome note before day one, from your onboarding tickets.
  • Fake executive requests that new hires reported in their first month, from the report button or the abuse mailbox.
  • Callbacks logged for payment or account change requests, from the finance approval log.

On day 30, read the reported count next to the 21,442 national complaint figure only for scale, and decide which step to tighten.

Questions people ask

How do I stop fake CEO emails to new hires at a 100-person fintech startup?

Brief each new hire before day one, give them one callback route, and turn on impersonation settings that cover a brand new mailbox. AegisAI investigates every email for what it is trying to do, and removes the ones that fail from every mailbox they reached.

Why do scammers target new employees?

Because the start date is public and the new hire has no baseline. Scammers might use a job update to target you. New hires are less likely to question directives that seem to come from the top.

Will a real CEO ask a new hire for gift cards?

Treat it as fake. Don't buy gift cards for anyone who contacts you to ask. Gift cards are for gifts, not for payments.

Does DMARC stop fake CEO emails?

Not on its own. Impersonation can pass email authentication checks if the attacker created a lookalike domain and published valid DNS records. Add lookalike domain protection and a callback step.

Does Microsoft 365 warn a new hire about a first-time sender?

Not in the first week. The first contact safety tip is not stamped when the message was sent to a mailbox created less than seven days ago. Brief the new hire before that week starts.

Sources

  1. (FTC Consumer Advice: New job? How to spot boss imposter scams. 11 July 2025)
  2. (FTC Consumer Advice: Your boss isn't emailing you about a gift card. 8 September 2021)
  3. (FBI IC3: 2024 Internet Crime Report)
  4. (FBI IC3: Business Email Compromise, The $55 Billion Scam. 11 September 2024)
  5. (FBI IC3: Business Email Compromise, The $50 Billion Scam. 9 June 2023)
  6. (Microsoft Learn: Anti-phishing policies in Microsoft 365. Updated 20 August 2026)
  7. (Google Workspace Admin Help: Advanced phishing and malware protection)
  8. (Security Info Watch: Socially engineered CEO impersonations target new hires. 30 January 2024)
  9. (AegisAI: Inbound email security)
  10. (AegisAI: BEC attack prevention)
  11. (AegisAI: How security teams stop CEO fraud and payroll diversion)
  12. (AegisAI: How universities stop payroll diversion and gift card scams)

Recent posts

Every email, investigated.