Book a demo →
← All posts

Graymail vs spam vs phishing: how to tell them apart

Graymail vs spam vs phishing: graymail is bulk mail some people want, spam is unsolicited, and phishing asks for your login or money. Learn to tell them apart.

Graymail vs spam vs phishing: how to tell them apart

Graymail vs spam vs phishing comes down to two questions: did the recipient ask for the mail, and does the message try to take something from them? Graymail is bulk mail that some recipients signed up for and others do not want. Spam is unsolicited and unwanted by nearly everyone. Phishing is a message that poses as a legitimate company to get login details, personal details or money, and it is the only one of the three that is an attack.

Graymail vs spam vs phishing: what is the difference?

Graymail is wanted by some, spam is wanted by no one, and phishing is built to deceive. Microsoft calls mail from bulk senders "bulk mail or gray mail" and says good bulk senders send desired messages to their subscribers1.

TypeWhat it isDid the recipient ask for it?
GraymailBulk mail, such as marketing messages or conference invitationsSometimes. Some recipients signed up on purpose, while others consider the same mail spam2
SpamAn unsolicited and universally unwanted message2No
PhishingUnsolicited email, text messages or calls that appear to come from a legitimate company and ask for personal, financial or login details3No

The line between graymail and spam is the recipient's choice, so the same newsletter can be graymail for one person and spam for another. The line between spam and phishing is intent. Spam is defined by being unsolicited. Phishing is defined by what it asks you to hand over.

How each one shows up in your spam filter

An email spam filter gives each of the three its own verdict. Microsoft 365 classifies messages as Spam, High confidence spam, Phishing, High confidence phishing or Bulk4.

Bulk mail gets a score. Microsoft assigns a bulk complaint level from 0 to 9. A 0 means the message is not from a bulk sender, 1 to 3 means few complaints, 4 to 7 a mixed number, and 8 to 9 a high number1.

The default threshold is 7, and bulk mail at or above it goes to the Junk Email folder. The Strict preset policy sets the threshold to 5 and quarantines the message instead1.

Microsoft handles phishing as a threat. High confidence phishing is always quarantined, and users cannot release it themselves4.

A folder does not tell you what a message is. Admins can set the action for the Phishing verdict to move the message to the Junk Email folder4, so a message in Junk can be phishing. Bulk mail can also land in a Promotions folder when an admin turns on the Bulk moves setting1. For more on why rule-based filters misfile mail, read a spam filter for the AI era.

How to tell graymail, spam and phishing apart in your inbox

Ask these questions in this order.

  1. Check whether you signed up for it. If you know the sender and remember subscribing, it is graymail. Look for an unsubscribe option. Microsoft's advice for complaints about bulk mail from reputable senders is to check for one2.
  2. Check whether anyone asked you for it. If you never signed up and the message only sells or advertises, it is spam.
  3. Check whether it asks for a login, personal details, a payment or a click on a sign-in or document link, in the name of a company or a person you know. If it does, treat it as phishing, whatever it looks like. The FBI's definition turns on that ask3.

If the message asks for any of those, stop. Do not use the button in the message. Open the service in a new tab and sign in there, as in anatomy of a password expiration phishing email.

Can phishing look like graymail?

Yes. Phishing can be built to look like a newsletter, with a sender that imitates a known provider, an unsubscribe line and one button. AegisAI describes this as look-alike newsletters built to be skimmed and clicked, and notes that keyword rules and sender reputation fail at both edges: they hold real invoices and deliver phishing sent as a newsletter5.

A second pattern uses volume as cover. In email bombing, a flood of sign-up confirmations arrives in minutes and buries one real alert, such as a password change notice5.

An unsubscribe line does not make a message graymail, so judge the sender and the ask.

Why the difference matters for security awareness training

Phishing is the one that causes losses, so training should keep it apart from the other two. In 2025, phishing and spoofing was the most reported crime type to the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center, with 191,561 complaints and $215,843,126 in reported losses3. IBM's 2025 study found phishing was the most frequent initial attack vector, at 16% of breaches, and those breaches averaged USD 4.8 million6.

AI adds to the volume. IBM reports that 16% of breaches involved attackers using AI, most often for AI-generated phishing (37%) and deepfake impersonation (35%)6.

Three habits keep staff from treating all three alike:

  1. Teach the questions above, in that order, with one real example of each from your own mail.
  2. Tell staff which mail to unsubscribe from and which to report. A message that fails the last question gets reported and never answered.
  3. Agree on one owner for graymail complaints, usually the IT admin who sets the bulk threshold, so complaints do not reach the security team as incidents.

What to do with each one when you find it

Each type needs a different action.

  • For graymail, unsubscribe from senders you know, or ask your admin to raise or lower the bulk threshold. Microsoft says there is no universal guidance for bulk mail, because users react to it differently2.
  • For spam, in Outlook, select the message, select Report, then Report junk. Outlook moves the message to the Junk Email folder and adds the sender to the user's Blocked Senders list7.
  • For phishing, in Outlook, select the message, select Report, then Report phishing. You can report phishing from any folder, and Outlook deletes the message7. If you clicked or typed anything, tell your security team at once.

If you cannot tell which type it is, report it as phishing and let your security team sort it.

Sort graymail, spam and phishing with AegisAI

AegisAI graymail and spam control uses the same agents that judge threats to sort bulk mail. Quarantine holds only what is dangerous, and graymail is cleared out of the inbox before users see or click it. Every message still gets the same investigation, links and files included, so a newsletter that carries an attack is judged as an attack.

There are no blocklists, allowlists or keyword rules to maintain. AegisAI reports 90% fewer false positives than rule-based filtering, a figure it measured in customer environments, and a median time to verdict of 1.9 seconds, bulk mail included.

Book a demo to see how AegisAI sorts a real mix of graymail, spam and phishing from your own mail.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between graymail, spam and phishing, and how do you tell them apart?

Graymail is bulk mail some recipients signed up for, spam is unsolicited mail nobody wanted, and phishing is a message that poses as a legitimate company to get login, personal or financial details2,3. To tell them apart, ask whether you signed up, whether anyone asked you for it, and whether it asks you for anything.

How does a spam filter treat graymail, spam and phishing differently?

The filter gives each its own verdict. Bulk mail gets a complaint score from 0 to 9 and a threshold, while phishing has its own verdict, and high confidence phishing is always quarantined4.

What are the key differences between phishing and spam emails?

Spam is unsolicited. Phishing is unsolicited too, but it also poses as a legitimate company to ask for personal, financial or login details2,3. Spam wastes time, while phishing aims at your account or your money.

Can a phishing email look like a legitimate newsletter or graymail message?

Yes. AegisAI describes look-alike newsletters built to be skimmed and clicked, with a sender that imitates a known provider and one button5. Check the sender address and the link destination before you trust anything in the footer.

How do you know if an email in your spam folder is dangerous or just unwanted?

You cannot tell from the folder. Microsoft 365 admins can send the Phishing verdict to the Junk Email folder4. Read the sender and the ask. If it asks for a login or a payment, report it as phishing.

What should you do when you find graymail, spam or phishing in your inbox?

Unsubscribe from graymail you know, report spam with Report junk, and report phishing with Report phishing, which deletes the message7. If you clicked or typed anything on a phishing message, tell your security team at once.

Sources

Newsletter

Don't miss the next big threat

New attack write-ups, product changes and practical defence notes, sent when there is something worth reading.